AI versus human engagement in the wellbeing space



In today’s fast-paced and demanding work environment, employees often face significant stress and mental health challenges. Recognising the importance of a mentally healthy workforce, forward-thinking organisations are exploring innovative solutions to address these issues. One potential avenue is the integration of Artificial Intelligence (AI) technology.  What about AI versus human engagement in the wellbeing space?


AI is gaining traction in supporting employee well-being, but I believe it is not yet on par with human intervention and care. Here’s a comparison between AI support and human intervention regarding employee well-being:


  1. Accessibility and Availability:
    • AI Support: AI systems can be available 24/7, providing instant responses to employees’ well-being needs, whether it’s through chatbots, virtual assistants, or online resources. This accessibility allows employees to seek help whenever they need it, even outside traditional working hours.
    • Human Intervention: Human support is typically available during working hours and may be limited to specific channels, such as face-to-face meetings or phone calls. Employees might have to schedule appointments or wait for the right time to access support.


  1. Consistency and Objectivity:
    • AI Support: AI systems can provide consistent and objective responses, free from human biases or emotions. They can follow predefined protocols and guidelines, ensuring every employee receives similar information and support.
    • Human Intervention: Human support may vary in consistency and objectivity, as individual care providers might have different approaches and personal biases that could influence the support provided.



  1. Depth of Understanding:
    • AI Support: AI can process large amounts of data and quickly identify patterns, trends, and correlations related to employee well-being. It can analyse data from various sources to suggest personalised recommendations.
    • Human Intervention: Humans have the advantage of empathy and emotional intelligence, allowing them to connect on a deeper level with employees. They can understand complex emotions, contextual factors, and unique situations, leading to more nuanced support.


  1. Emotional Support:
    • AI Support: While AI chatbots can be programmed to provide empathetic responses and understanding, their responses are based on algorithms and patterns rather than genuine emotional connections.
    • Human Intervention: Human caregivers can offer genuine emotional support and establish meaningful relationships with employees, which can have a profound impact on their well-being.


  1. Complexity of Issues:
    • AI Support: AI is more suited for addressing routine and straightforward well-being concerns, offering resources, tips, and general advice. It might struggle with handling complex and sensitive issues that require a deeper understanding of the individual’s circumstances.
    • Human Intervention: Trained professionals can handle a wide range of complex well-being issues, including mental health, interpersonal conflicts, and career challenges, through counselling, coaching, or therapy.


  1. Confidentiality and Trust:
    • AI Support: AI systems may raise concerns about data privacy and security, which can impact employees’ willingness to share sensitive information.
    • Human Intervention: Human support providers are bound by professional ethics and confidentiality standards, fostering trust and a safe environment for employees to share their concerns.


In conclusion, while AI support can offer quick and accessible information on general well-being topics, human intervention provides a more profound and personalised level of care, especially for complex emotional issues. AI is continually advancing, but it has not replaced the value of human connection and empathy in supporting employee well-being.


As AI technology continues to advance, it has significant potential to enhance mental health in the workplace. However, it is crucial to strike a balance between AI-powered solutions and maintaining a human touch in providing support and understanding, particularly for employees facing mental health challenges for example.


By combining the strengths of AI and human empathy, organisations have an opportunity to create a truly inclusive and supportive workplace for their most valuable asset – their people.


About P3 Business Care


P3 Business Care is a Community Interest Company and social enterprise operating across the UK. Supporting your business on a weekly basis we provide personal face-to-face proactive care to your employees and immediate family working in partnership with the company. Our Business Partners visit your business weekly developing trust & relationships so we can identify and address issues before they become crisis, absence,  staff turnover or worse!  Read more about our services here

The Top 6 Ways to improve care for your employees!


Are you stressed trying to manage your staff? We feel your pain! Read about the top 6 ways to improve care for your employees.

You have Successfully Subscribed!